Informal Taxes and Corruption in North Korea

North Korea, officially known as the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (DPRK), remains one of the world’s most secretive and isolated nations. With a strict totalitarian regime controlled by the Kim family dynasty, the country is often portrayed as a realm of strict state control over all aspects of life, including the economy. However, beneath the veneer of absolute government control lies a complex web of informal taxes and widespread corruption, which play significant roles in the everyday lives of North Koreans and the functioning of the country’s shadow economy.

**Economic Background**

North Korea’s economy has long been characterized by a centralized plan, which means that all economic activities are orchestrated by the state. The government owns all means of production, and private enterprise is officially prohibited. Over the years, various sanctions imposed by the international community, especially after the country’s ongoing nuclear weapons and ballistic missile programs, have further isolated North Korea economically.

Despite this isolation and stringent state control, an informal, market-driven economy has emerged and grown since the 1990s. The great famine of the mid-1990s, which led to the collapse of the Public Distribution System (PDS), forced many North Koreans to engage in private trading or “jangmadang” markets to survive. These markets, while technically illegal, have become a critical component of everyday life in North Korea.

**Informal Taxes**

Given the state’s official stance against private enterprise, engaging in such activities often necessitates paying informal taxes to various officials to turn a blind eye. These informal taxes, sometimes referred to as **bribes** or “fees,” are paid to local officials, police officers, and sometimes even military personnel. They serve as a form of **protection money** that allows merchants and individuals to operate within these markets without interference from the government.

In some regions, the rates of these informal taxes can be quite high. Merchants typically need to pay a portion of their earnings, which can vary depending on the type of goods they are selling, the region, and the official collecting the tax. This creates a significant burden on traders but also provides a substantial income for the corrupt officials involved.

**Corruption in Government and Society**

Corruption is rampant throughout North Korean society and government. It is not limited to the petty officials collecting bribes from market traders; it permeates all levels of the state apparatus. High-ranking officials often exploit their positions to amass wealth and goods, which they can then use to secure loyalty and maintain their power. The critical points where corruption is most prevalent include:

– **State Enterprises**: Officials frequently siphon off resources from state enterprises, which are often left underfunded and underperforming as a result.
– **Humanitarian Aid**: There have been numerous reports of humanitarian aid intended for the North Korean populace being diverted and sold on the black market.
– **Smuggling Networks**: Some government officials are involved in smuggling goods into and out of the country, circumventing both domestic laws and international sanctions.

**Impact on Society**

The pervasive corruption and informal taxation system in North Korea have a profound impact on society. On the one hand, they perpetuate inequality and injustice, with those in power exploiting their positions for personal gain. On the other hand, the emergence of these informal market structures and the ability to bribe officials have provided North Koreans with a limited degree of economic freedom and opportunity. This has fostered a form of resilience and entrepreneurial spirit among the population.

Nevertheless, the system also means that the North Korean government cannot exert complete control over the economy, leading to a paradox where the state is both all-encompassing and undermined by its own corrupt practices.

**Conclusion**

The phenomenon of informal taxes and corruption in North Korea highlights the reality of life under one of the most repressive regimes in the world. While the state maintains a strict official stance against private enterprise, the survival and proliferation of informal markets speak to the resilience of the North Korean people in the face of extreme state control. Corruption, far from being merely a socio-political ill, has become a crucial mechanism that enables both officials and ordinary citizens to navigate the complexities of life in North Korea.

Suggested Related Links about Informal Taxes and Corruption in North Korea:

Human Rights Watch

Transparency International

BBC

Reuters

Council on Foreign Relations